By Rafaela Martins
Despite the common belief that selling a building unit by unit always earns more than selling it whole, what I see is that the question is badly framed. You are not choosing a price. You are choosing between two different deals: one that ends with a single deed, and another that only ends with the last one.
The first search results on this topic are building listings and forum threads about horizontal property. Almost none connect the decision to the three things that really change it: who can buy, how much capital stays tied up and for how long, and which taxes change with the calendar. Let us take it step by step.
What are you really deciding between selling a building whole or by units?
Selling the whole building is a wholesale sale: one buyer, one negotiation, one deed. The price per square metre tends to be lower, because the buyer takes on the work, the risk and the time still ahead.
Selling by units is a retail sale: many buyers, many negotiations, one deed per home. The price per square metre can be higher, but you only get paid as each home sells, and the construction, licensing and market risk stay with the seller until the end.
The gap between the two prices is not profit. It is the reward for the time, capital and risk you choose to keep.
Who buys a whole building, and who buys a single unit?
These are audiences that barely overlap, and that matters more than it seems.
- Whole building: few buyers (developers, investors with their own capital, family offices). They work the numbers backwards: they start from the final sale value, deduct works, costs, taxes and the margin they want, and arrive at the price they offer. They negotiate with that spreadsheet in hand.
- Single unit: many buyers, most of them with a mortgage. The bank lends on the valuation, not on the asking price. As I explained in the article on buying a home with a mortgage in Portugal in 2026, it is the valuation that decides whether the deed happens.
Market context matters for both. According to INE, Portugal’s statistics office, in the second quarter of 2026 the median price of homes sold in the municipality of Lisbon was €5,299/m², the highest in the country, but growth in Lisbon slowed and the number of transactions nationwide fell compared with the previous quarter. A unit-by-unit sale that takes two years is more exposed to that change of pace than a single sale.
And a note I always repeat: prices on property portals are asking prices, not sale prices. The serious benchmark is deeds and bank valuations.
How does capital change when you sell a building by units?
For me, this is the most underestimated point. Bank financing for development usually works against progress certificates: the bank pays for work done, it does not advance work still to do. Equity goes in first and has to cover the start and the gap between each certificate, as I described in urban rehabilitation in Lisbon: from opportunity to sale.
In practice, the choice changes the capital profile like this:
- Selling the whole building, before or after the works: the capital comes back in one go. The execution risk passes to the buyer.
- Selling by units after the works: the capital stays tied up until the last deed. Every month without a sale means interest, condominium fees, insurance and property tax (IMI).
- Selling by units off-plan or during the works: deposits from promissory contracts can ease the capital need, but they create obligations to each buyer (deadlines, specifications, returning double the deposit if the seller fails). I wrote about this from the buyer’s side in buying off-plan property in Portugal.
The right question is not “how much more do I make per unit?”. It is “can I hold the capital until the last home sells, if the market slows down?”.
Which taxes change the numbers between the two options?
Two points deserve attention before any decision, and both depend on the calendar.
- IMT exemption when buying for resale. Whoever buys a building for resale may be exempt from IMT (property transfer tax), but the exemption lapses if the resale does not happen within one year of the deed. In a binding ruling dated 9 April 2026, the Portuguese Tax Authority confirmed that this period cannot be interrupted: renovation works, licences or delays do not suspend it. Once the exemption lapses, the IMT must be paid within 30 days. One year is rarely enough to license, build and sell home by home.
- Horizontal property and the same exemption. Since Law 56/2023 (Mais Habitação), the IMT Code treats changes that alter the tax value of the property as a “different use”. In binding rulings from 2024 and 2025, the Tax Authority held that the exemption lapses if, after the horizontal property is set up, the number of units or their permilage changes. Some contest this reading and, according to an analysis published in ECO, there is still no case law on it. Buying a whole building to divide and sell by units while counting on the exemption is today a tax risk to validate before buying.
Then there is VAT on the works. The regime of Decree-Law 97/2026 allows a 6% rate on construction or rehabilitation contracts for permanent own housing or rental, under conditions: sale at a moderate price (around €661,000, the limit of the second IMT bracket) and within 24 months of first use. In a building under horizontal property, the rate applies to the share of units that meet that purpose. It is a regime designed for selling home by home to people who will live there, not for selling the building to an investor.
None of these points is decided on its own. They should be settled with your accountant before signing, not after.
What needs to be in place to sell a building by units?
Selling by units is not first a commercial decision; it is a legal condition. Under the Portuguese Civil Code, only units that are independent, distinct and separate from each other, with their own access to a common part of the building or to the street, can be autonomous units. In an old Lisbon building this is not always guaranteed from the start: shared staircases, attics, courtyards and annexes have to fit the project.
Before the first deed, the minimum is:
- horizontal property set up and registered, with permilages defined;
- planning title and occupancy permit, which the new licensing regime requires to be mentioned in contracts;
- a clean registry position, including the consent of anyone holding a charge on the building, such as a bank;
- a planned order of sale: the first homes sold set the benchmark for the next ones, and the next buyer’s bank valuer will look at them.
Whoever sells the whole building can leave part of this work to the buyer. Whoever sells by units has to have done all of it.
So, how do you decide?
When I analyse a building with this question, I ask five things, in this order:
- Does the building divide well? If the units do not meet the requirements or end up with areas and access that are hard to sell, the answer is already given.
- Is there capital to hold until the last deed? In a scenario where the sale takes twice as long as planned.
- What types of home are they? Small homes sell to buyers with a mortgage and depend on the valuation; large homes depend on fewer buyers and more time.
- Which tax regime applies, and with what deadlines? IMT on the purchase, VAT on the works, taxation on the sale.
- What is the net difference? The value of the units, minus marketing costs, time, interest and risk, compared with a firm offer for the building. If the difference does not pay for the risk, selling whole is the rational decision.
It is not about selling for more. It is about choosing which risk you want to carry, and for how long.
Investing with strategy, here, means accepting that the best sale is not always the one with the highest price on paper.
If you own a building in Lisbon and are weighing these two routes, write to me at contato@thereachrealestate.com or on WhatsApp (+351 912 588 145).
By Rafaela Martins
This article is for information only and does not replace legal or tax advice.
Reference sources
- Portal das Finanças, binding ruling no. 29664 (IMT Code, art. 11), 09/04/2026 (in Portuguese, accessed 17/11/2026)
- ECO, “Fisco trava isenção de IMT na revenda de casas”, 13/04/2026 (in Portuguese, accessed 17/11/2026)
- ECO (opinion), “Isenção de IMT por revenda e propriedade horizontal”, 13/11/2025 (in Portuguese, accessed 17/11/2026)
- Morais Leitão, “Pacote Fiscal da Habitação 2026” (Decree-Law 97/2026), May 2026 (in Portuguese, accessed 17/11/2026)
- Observador, house prices rose 18.4% in the second quarter, INE data, 23/10/2026 (in Portuguese, accessed 10/11/2026)
- Portuguese Civil Code, articles 1414 and 1415 (horizontal property)
